For an elderly woman whose farmland was affected by the February 18, 2025 toxic spill linked to Sino Metals Leach Zambia Limited, the Supreme Court battle is about more than legal arguments.
Her immediate concern is how she will feed her family.
For years, she relied on farming to put food on the table. But since the spill, she says she has been prevented from cultivating her land.
Now, as another farming season begins, she wants to know whether she can return to her fields.
“Last year, they stopped us from farming. Are they going to allow us this year, since they say they have cleaned the area?” she asked a lawyer briefing about 20 affected residents after the latest court adjournment.
The Supreme Court has adjourned, for the fourth time, an appeal by Sino Metals against a High Court decision allowing a constitutional petition by 177 residents affected by the spill to proceed.
The latest adjournment, granted on November 18, 2026, gives the parties more time to explore a possible settlement.
A three-member panel comprising Justices Nigel Mutuna, Fulgency Mwenya Chisanga and Abha Nayar Patel granted the application by Attorney General Mulilo Kabesha.
Justice Mutuna, however, warned that the court would not entertain further adjournments, stressing the need to conclude the matter without further delay.
Lawyers for the petitioners and Sino Metals did not oppose the application.
The petitioners are represented by Malambo and Company Advocates and Lusitu Chambers, while Sino Metals is represented by Chibesakunda & Company.
The government, which is convening settlement discussions, says it wants the negotiations to address the concerns of everyone affected by the spill, including those who are not parties to the case.
In an affidavit supporting the adjournment application seen by MakanDay, Mr Kabesha argued that the dispute extended beyond the interests of the litigants to other members of the public affected by the spill.
He said the government had consulted the parties and other stakeholders and that officials had visited Mutenda, a proposed relocation site for affected residents.
Mr Kabesha said substantial progress had been made towards resolving the dispute, but more time was needed to complete consultations and verify the circumstances of affected residents.
He argued that the adjournment would allow the government to present a comprehensive settlement framework to the Supreme Court.
The affidavit, however, gives no timetable for completing the verification exercise, finalising compensation arrangements or relocating affected households.
Resettlement raises fresh concerns
Questions remain about how Sino Metals and the government are handling resettlement and restoring livelihoods following the toxic spill.
On November 18, the same day the Supreme Court heard the appeal in Lusaka, Sino Metals and government officials met affected residents in Kalusale, one of the areas affected by the spill, to discuss resettlement.
Kalusale branch chairman Chibwe Kabunda confirmed to MakanDay that the meeting was attended by Permanent Secretary in the Office of the Vice-President Mavis Nkomesha and Kalulushi District Commissioner Mubita Ikashakala.
Sino Metals reportedly told residents it had built 60 houses for resettlement.
Mr Kabunda said some residents received housing offer letters that day, while others were taken to view the houses and given keys on November 19.
MakanDay has obtained a copy of an official letter issued by the Office of the Vice-President’s Resettlement Division, confirming the allocation of a plot of land at a government resettlement scheme in Copperbelt Province.
The letter identifies the recipient as a Project Affected Person (PAP) under the Kalusale Resettlement Action Plan (RAP).
“This letter authorises you to take occupation of the plot,” it states.
The recipient is required to observe the plot’s surveyed boundaries and formally accept the offer by signing and returning a copy of the letter to the Scheme Manager’s office.
However, the letter does not establish whether the recipient accepted the offer or took possession of the land.
Although the letter refers to the Kalusale Resettlement Action Plan, affected residents and their lawyers say they have not been given access to the document, raising questions about whether those being relocated have been adequately informed of the resettlement arrangements.
A source who attended the court hearing in Lusaka said some residents were contacted afterwards and asked where they had left their national registration cards (NRCs).
Others received calls from their children saying officials wanted to deliver housing offer letters.
The source alleged that residents who refused the offers were warned not to return to the area and told their houses would be demolished if they did. MakanDay has not established who issued the alleged warnings.
Another source said the reported threats had frightened some residents, who had called to express their concerns.
The source added that some residents had travelled to Lusaka for the court hearing, and had only learnt about the resettlement meeting on November 17.
The accounts raise questions about whether residents were adequately consulted and given enough information to make informed decisions about relocation.
The government’s December 2025 resettlement action plan (RAP) approval checklist sets out requirements covering consultation, compensation, basic services and livelihood restoration, rather than housing alone.
It remains unclear whether Sino Metals has submitted an RAP, obtained government approval or included the reported 60 houses in an approved resettlement programme.
For affected residents, including the elderly woman who lost access to her farmland, the concern is not only where they will live, but how they will rebuild their livelihoods.
She remains worried about the condition of the land despite reported efforts to clean up the affected area.
“They say they added lime to address the problem,” she said. “But when it rains and water collects, I still see white foam forming.”
Legal dispute continues
The appeal arises from a High Court decision allowing a constitutional petition filed by 177 residents affected by the February 2025 spill to proceed.
The residents are seeking to hold Sino Metals accountable for the alleged environmental, economic and social harm caused by the disaster. They say the spill damaged crops, contaminated water sources and disrupted livelihoods.
Non-Ferrous China Africa (NFCA) Mining Plc, within whose mining area the tailings dams were located, is also named in the proceedings.
Sino Metals, a subsidiary of the Chinese state-owned China Nonferrous Metal Mining Group, operates in Chambishi in Kalulushi District on the Copperbelt.
The dispute follows the collapse of mining waste containment facilities in February 2025, which released acidic and toxic waste into nearby waterways, including the Chambishi Stream, Mwambashi River and the wider Kafue River system.
The Supreme Court previously allowed the Attorney General to join the proceedings, recognising the government’s interest in the matter.
The appeal remains unresolved as efforts to negotiate a settlement outside court continue.
Expansion plans raise further environmental questions
Sino Metals is also seeking approval to expand another tailings storage facility at its Chambishi operations.
As MakanDay previously reported, the company wants to increase the capacity of its TD15G facility from approximately 1.84 million cubic metres to 5.48 million cubic metres, almost three times its current capacity.
The expansion would increase the facility’s footprint from about 13 hectares to 47 hectares.
TD15G is separate from TD15F, the facility identified by the government as having failed during the 2025 spill.
The Zambia Environmental Management Agency has been reviewing an environmental and social impact assessment submitted for the proposed expansion.
The Zambia Environmental Justice Coalition has raised concerns, calling for critical safety and environmental information to be made public and independently scrutinised before approval is granted.
Company response
MakanDay contacted Permanent Secretary in the Office of the Vice-President Ms Nkomesha for comment on the resettlement arrangements. She advised MakanDay to visit her office on Friday, November 20.
MakanDay also sought comment from Sino Metals on the reported construction of 60 houses, its resettlement plans and measures to restore affected livelihoods. The company had not responded by the time this report was prepared.

Discover more from MAKANDAY
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.