HomeLatest NewsThe court ordered their release, but they stayed in custody for 20...

The court ordered their release, but they stayed in custody for 20 more days.

By Gibson Zulu

The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), Gilbert Phiri, has referred questions about the continued detention of two Lusaka men for 20 days after the High Court ordered their release to the Zambia Police Service and other law enforcement agencies.

In a written response to MakanDay dated 13 November 2026, Mr Phiri acknowledged the court’s order releasing Solomon Mbewe, 26, and Felix Chipili, 22, but said the National Prosecution Authority (NPA) had no operational mandate over the management of people in custody.

The response follows a request for comment sent by MakanDay on 4 November, when the two men were still in detention despite the DPP having discontinued aggravated robbery proceedings against them and the Lusaka High Court ordering their release on 23 October. Mbewe and Chipili were eventually released on 12 November, 20 days after the court order.

The men had already spent more than nine months in detention after their arrest on 3 February 2026.

In his response, Mr Phiri said the responsibility for enforcing the law, including arrests and the management of people in custody, rested with the police and other relevant law enforcement agencies.

“The National Prosecution Authority does not have the operational mandate to manage detention facilities or determine the circumstances surrounding the continued physical custody of individuals,” he wrote.

He added that concerns about the continued detention of the two men, including its legal basis, should be directed to the relevant law enforcement agencies.

MakanDay also sought clarification from the Zambia Police Service on why the two men remained in custody despite the High Court’s release order. However, the police did not respond to the query.

However, the DPP’s response did not explain why the two men remained in custody after the High Court ordered their release on 23 October. It also did not directly confirm or deny an allegation that his office had instructed that the two men be re-arrested.

As previously reported by MakanDay, a family member said a senior state advocate had informed the family that he had received instructions from the DPP to have Mbewe and Chipili re-arrested.

Asked to clarify whether such instructions had been issued, Phiri referred MakanDay to law enforcement agencies.

“With regard to the allegation that this Office instructed that the two individuals be re-arrested, you are advised to seek clarification from the relevant law enforcement agencies regarding the circumstances surrounding any subsequent arrest and the legal basis thereof,” he said.

DPP defends decision to discontinue prosecution

In the same response, Mr Phiri defended his office’s decision to discontinue the aggravated robbery proceedings against the two men, citing his constitutional authority to terminate criminal prosecutions.

He referred to Article 180(3) of the Constitution, which establishes the DPP as the government’s chief prosecutor and head of the NPA, and Article 180(4)(c), which empowers the DPP to discontinue criminal proceedings before judgment.

He also cited Section 81 of the Criminal Procedure Code, which provides for the entry of a nolle prosequi, a formal decision to discontinue criminal proceedings.

“The entry of a nolle prosequi in the matter on 23rd October, 2026, was therefore an exercise of the constitutional and statutory prosecutorial authority vested in the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions,” he stated.

Mr Phiri also acknowledged the subsequent court order for the release of the accused persons.

The two men had pleaded not guilty to aggravated robbery when their trial began before Lusaka High Court Judge Mutinta Kaumbi Ndulo-Mundia on 5 October 2026.

After several adjournments, the DPP entered a nolle prosequi on 23 October, bringing the proceedings to an end.

Following the discontinuance, Justice Ndulo-Mundia ordered the two men discharged from custody.

Under Section 81(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code, the entry of a nolle prosequi requires an accused person to be discharged from custody in relation to the discontinued proceedings, although the State may subsequently institute fresh proceedings on the same facts.

Despite the order, Mbewe and Chipili remained in custody until 12 November.

Families referred to law enforcement agencies

In his response, Mr Phiri also advised the families of the two men to seek clarification from law enforcement agencies about the circumstances of their detention.

“The families of the affected individuals may wish to follow up with the relevant law enforcement agencies to establish the circumstances surrounding the continued detention of the two individuals and obtain guidance on the appropriate next steps,” he wrote.

The DPP’s response came after MakanDay sent a follow-up query on 4 November, seeking an explanation for the continued detention and clarification of the alleged re-arrest instruction.

MakanDay had also raised the matter in an earlier correspondence dated 25 September 2026.

Mr Phiri said the issues raised in the subsequent correspondence had been addressed in his response.

Although the two men are now free, the DPP’s response leaves several questions unanswered: what legal authority was used to keep them in custody after the High Court ordered their release, whether they were formally re-arrested, and who authorised their continued detention.

Related story: Two Lusaka Men Freed 20 Days After High Court Ordered Their Release


Discover more from MAKANDAY

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

RELATED ARTICLES

Leave a Reply

Most Popular

Recent Comments